Showing posts with label Money. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Money. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 21, 2015

Bank of America Fails Again... How Big Banks Are Losing Touch With Their Customers



Inside Bank of America in Chinatown is an ad for "low car loan rates", the bank has a stand-up, interactive cardboard sign where customers can guess "What Kind of Car Are You?". According to StreetsBlogSF, Chinatown "has the city's lowest rate of car ownership". Too bad Bank of America didn't get the memo.

With only one teller helping over five customers in line, many of whom opt out of the Snap With Your App Check Deposit, frustration with the bank and its ignorance of customer service was high.

As I was standing, waiting to pay off my credit card and get some quarters for laundry, an older man gave a great big sigh behind me.

One bank woman got another woman from in back of the bank to help an elderly gentleman who had some sort of bank problem. Since they were talking in Chinese, I had no idea what the problem was but they were standing there for a good ten minutes or more.

An older woman who came into the bank, spoke in Chinese with the younger man at Bank of America who was greeting everyone at the door. I'm sure she was complaining about the long wait times in line. It turns out, this is an everyday occurrence and at this location (Grant Avenue), it wasn't much of an improvement from the other Bank of America branch just down the street (Stockton Street).

The median age for those living in Chinatown is 52-years-old (Realtor.com). Many of the people here do in-person banking and don't use their phones for banking deposits, online banking or appointments. Bank of America, instead of compensating for this particular demographic at its branches, is instead opting to exclude them.

The result? More frustrated elderly customers who will take their money elsewhere, to the many convenient Chinese banks in Chinatown.

Greeters at the banks encourage customers to use the ATM's to do their banking for deposits, instead of in-person with a teller.

I was told while I was waiting in line that I could deposit my money into an ATM.

"What happens if the ATM shreds my money and checks?" I asked. I had heard of this happening with other people at other locations.

"Oh, that won't happen." The Chinese bank woman assured me but instead I remained in line until five minutes later, I was still waiting in line for a deposit. I ended up leaving and making my deposit into Mechanics Bank instead.

Where Else Can You Go?


Credit Unions are another popular alternative. With the Huffington Post "Move Your Money" Campaign, many Americans moved their money from big conglomerate banks to local credit unions. I'm looking to do the same with SF Fire Credit Union, as they offer similar benefits like Bank of America without all the hassle. They even have a coin deposit machine with Coinstar, where customers get a receipt for deposit instead of dealing with paper rolls and penning in account numbers.

Credit Card Hassle


Suffering from credit card theft or having your credit card information stolen is bad enough but when banks (and employers) use this against you, that's just hitting below the belt. Did you know you have to state who your employer is on your credit card? They always check to make sure you're employed.

When I last checked my credit card information (due to a recent information theft), I was shocked to find BofA still had my old employer on my credit card... from 2010! They had never bothered to update this, even after I went in to tell them I moved, changed employers, student status, etc. There's not much communication between BofA and any of its products.

Have you been offered one of those super-high-interest-rates card with extra points and bonus offers? According to Bank of America's Terms and Conditions of BankAmericard Cash Rewards, you could be paying more APR, "Up to 29.99%, based on your creditworthiness.". Also, if you don't spend a lot of money, you may not get all the benefits. "You will earn base cash rewards of 1% for Net Purchases in excess of $1,500 in each quarter in the Bonus Categories." Forget trying to use your card at discount places, since BofA doesn't want poor people using this card. "... please note superstores, discount stores and warehouse clubs are not included in this list".

Doesn't really encourage you to get their credit card, does it? So basically, the card only rewards rich people who spend a bunch of money at high-end stores and gas-guzzling hummers (are people still driving those?).

Privacy Invasion


Mysterious phone calls are also a part of being a BofA customer, though how they get your phone number from the "Do-Not-Call-List" is another mystery. Even if you Opt-out of those offers Bank of America has, their subsidiaries and other companies can contact you--no matter what.

Bank of America Corporation website (https://www.bankofamerica.com/privacy/faq/privacy-choices-faq.go), Your Privacy Choices FAQ's, states:

  • What is the five-year opt out language?
When you opt out of direct marketing by mail or telephone, your opt out(s) will last for five years, subject to applicable law. After that, you can choose to renew your opt out(s) for another five-year period.
  • Does this five-year expiration apply also to opt outs from third party or affiliate sharing?
No, this applies only to the direct marketing opt out for mail or phone contacts.

On those pieces of paper they sometimes mail to you, your choices to Opt-out are limited and BofA still shares your information to others: credit bureaus, businesses, corporations, etc. They share your employment information, your social security number, your living address(es), past rental history, overdue bills and all the things you once thought were private. 

Bank of America Corporation, Set your Privacy Choices, states again:

The types of personal information we collect and share depend on the product or service you have with us.
This information can include:
  • Social Security number and employment information
  • account balances, transaction history and credit information
  • assets and investment experience


Time For Change


If you see this happening at your bank, it's a sign of the times. Due to the 2008 financial crisis and loan fraud fiasco, many people are now skeptical of doing business with banks.

People lost their homes while big bank CEO's and financial advisors got billions of dollars in profits--and they're still getting them. After the bank bailout, courtesy of the U.S.A. government, banks are doing everything they can to keep their profits and as a result, customers are suffering.

Staff cuts, over-reliance on technology and the Online/App crap phase has hit its way into everyday transactions and has made both customers and bank workers very unhappy.

More and more, people are going without paper money or checks. You can even pay rent with a credit card now, though you may have to up your limit to several thousand for San Francisco's rent. RadPad boasts that customers can pay with a credit or debit card and RadPad will mail a paper check to the landlord. It also accepts Apple Pay.

Mobile phones are now used in place of check deposits, direct deposits, cash deposits and coin deposits. That's great for the techies but what if you don't use mobile phones for your banking due to: fraud, hacking, old phones, etc. What if something goes wrong with your phone? Do you really want to keep all that information in some information cloud?

Keeping diverse accounts in multiple banks may be a good idea, except when banks get bought over.

I was once with World Savings Bank, which offered great service, great interest rates and great perks. Then World Savings Bank became Wachovia, which then became Wells Fargo, which made me a very unhappy customer. I then moved my account to a local credit union.


How To Make Change


So, in short, there's not much you can do about Bank of America, Wells Fargo or any of its conglomerates who still hold America and its customers by a financial stranglehold. Many people are stuck with them for home, car and student loans. Some have family accounts that if broken may suffer penalties as a result.

What can you do? Make change! Remember all those tedious paper rolls I was talking about earlier? Use those for your pennies and deposit those into the bank instead of money, checks or direct deposit (assuming you have your main accounts at credit unions). Just keep that one BofA account going, for whatever trap they had put you in, and do the "My Two Cents" deposit until they add up.

Here's what I imagine would happen...

Lines of people around the block (this would be an organized protest on big banks), waiting to deposit their coins. "My Two Cents" would show banks that people want in-person service, respect for all their money and to make banks realize that other people, not just the billionaires, do business with them.

Even if the banks get a coin machine, there would only be one (due to banks' penny-pinching habits) and people would still have to line up to make their deposits.

Assuming people have time to do this (which the unemployed do), this can be done.

Just do the underpaid and overworked bank tellers a favor: put the account numbers on the coin rolls and fill out the deposit sheet properly. Oh, and don't wait for payday, better make it Tuesday instead.

* * *

Emerald Behrens, currently resides in San Francisco, where she writes about social injustice, homelessness and human frailty in general. She is a freelance writer, poet and author of "My Private Collection". She may be contacted at: emerarudo83 (at) gmail (dot) com.

Contents of blog and article subject to copyright. Not for use or copy without author's permission.

Friday, July 3, 2015

Let’s Talk About Money

I was going over my finances, like I do every few months, and decided to write down all my expenses so far (not counting entertainment, coffee, eating out, etc.). I was trying to figure out how much I could save if I got a better paying job, now that minimum wage in San Francisco is $12.25 an hour.

Turns out, I won't be saving anything after all...

Here are my expenses:

Rent $850/month $10,200/year

Rent in San Francisco is insane and I'm lucky to get a studio (no bath or kitchen) at this price. I got a lease, so I'll see how long that lasts. There is rent control here but it's a tricky situation that has kept many local and state lawyers busy (and well employed).

Health Insurance $285/month $3,420/year

I never needed health insurance, until a disastrous situation put me in a "hospital" against my will. Rather than paying $32,000+ for those bills, my health insurance put out $15,000+ and cut it down to a reasonable amount for me to pay in monthly installments, somewhere around $5,000+.

Not bad... but now I don't think I can afford health insurance anymore. San Francisco has their own health insurance but I don't work here to qualify and I really don't want to be on Medi-Cal because I've heard horror stories about it.

Storage $180/month $2,160/year

Do I really need all that junk in my storage? No. But how do I get rid of it? That's a problem that has plagued me for 3+ years now. Yes, for three years I've been paying storage fees because my family used to live in a four bedroom three bath house and now I'm on my own in a studio with no way to get all my things back to the way it used to be. Not all that stuff is mine, true, but if I were to pack all my stuff: books, books, more books and some furniture... I'd really be crammed in this remodeled hotel room I'm living in now. This is a work in progress.

PG&E $60/month $720/year

Since my last bill so far was $4.44, I have no idea what my next bill will be but I'm basing it off of previous bills I've had with PG&E. Unfortunately, due to much red tape and meaningless "Poverty Levels for a Family of One Household", I don't qualify for PG&E handouts. How much electricity can I use with only a computer, printer, rice cooker, hot water pot and fluorescent lights? I may have to update this later.

YMCA $62/month $744/year

Yes, I belong to the YMCA which is right handy for me. I may not use the gym that much or go to all of the yoga classes but they have an indoor swimming pool, as San Francisco's summer weather reaches a ridiculous high of 70 degrees fahrenheit without fog. They also have clean showers. I live in a studio and shared bath with only three bathrooms on four floors, with over 60+ people sharing them. Figure it out.

AT&T $51.98/month $623.76/year

I am going to cut AT&T even though I've been with them 10+ years. They inform me that I'm on "the cheapest plan" but I'm not convinced. My phone bill is supposed to be $39.99 but they add in all these extras and taxes, including a very shady Administration Fee of $0.61 that was not approved by customers. Needless to say, I could write another article just on how much AT&T rips me off. Now I just have to figure out how to transfer data from a very old flip-phone to my monthly to-go smartphone.

StraightTalk $40/month $480/year

Recently, StraightTalk along with TracPhone was involved in a lovely scam where they "throttled" data speeds, even though customers paid money for Unlimited Data Nationwide. Unfortunately, I missed this FCC claim process because StraightTalk conveniently did not send me a letter, as they were supposed to, informing me that I had a right to a refund.

However, since I had to use my smartphone to get my cheap $850/year lease in San Francisco, I'm willing to forgive them this once and continue to shell out money for their product that I desperately need. So far my data limit is under 3GB, so I should be fine. But I would rather have this phone than pay more money for AT&T. I'm also using Google Voice but we'll see how long that lasts before I have to pay for that too.

Bus/MUNI/BART in San Francisco $83/month $996/year

I get a monthly pass for $83.00 and if my card gets stolen (like it did a few days ago), I get a replacement with all my benefits and money sent to me for just $5.00.

San Francisco is one of the few cities in the United States of America, where you don't need a car. I don't have a car anymore but luckily, I don't need one here. San Francisco has three options for transportation: Bus, MUNI and BART (along with those sketchy: Über, Lyft, etc. rideshares that take money away from city-licensed taxi drivers). I don't ride my bike here (yet) but even walking is possible where I live and as long as I live in San Francisco (hopefully forever), I will never need a car except to rent one when I go out of town [promo plug-in for Enterprise-Rent-A-Car here].

Comcast $54.95/month $659.40/year

Without Comcast Internet, I wouldn't be writing this to you now. Internet has become one of the most important utilities in civilization: more than a phone, TV, radio (or even Gas/Petroleum). Because, without this communication you couldn't: find a place to live, find a job, find your way around town, sell junk you don't need, find unemployment, etc. We should all have free internet in this country with sufficient speeds to adequately complete these daily activities (no streaming movies, etc.). Let me write it again: We should all have free internet in this country with sufficient speeds to adequately complete these daily activities (no streaming movies, etc.).

For the time being though, this monthly cost will be the last thing I cut from my budget and I'd rather cut food for it. I'm using a Wi-Fi to-go plan which may be eliminated soon so I have to use it while I can.

Food $200/month $2,400/year

$40/week × 5 =$200. I'm not sure if this is a strict budget or not. I shop at Safeway and try to get gluten-free products there. Due to my Celiac Disease (it's a disease, not a diet!), I can't have bread, so this significantly changes my whole budget. Gluten-free food is ridiculously expensive. Lucky for me, I like Asian food and can get by with rice but there's only so much you can do before your tastebuds start yelling, "I'm bored! Get me sugar and chocolate!". So yeah... I'll see if I can cut this down without cutting my weight down too.

So... how much is this all costing me, you ask? I'm guessing you're bad at math like I am. Here's the answer:

$1,866.93 a month. $22,403.16 a year.

Seems like a lot, doesn't it?

For one person, I'm sure it is. So given my circumstances (and unemployment situation), I was willing to cut a few things, should my purse become a bit lighter in the future.

Without Health Insurance, AT&T, Storage and YMCA, my expenses would be:

$1,287.95 a month $15,467.16 a year.

(Cutting those expenses I listed would save me: $578.98 a month and $6,936 a year.)

Now, here comes the reality check. If I don't find a job and my situation gets worse, I'll have to make more cuts. Let's call it, the Major Crunch. I want to keep my Bus/MUNI/BART, internet for job and school and smartphone to keep my life going but if worse comes to worse I can live without it, though it would really, really, suck.

Here's the breakdown on Absolute Living Expenses With No Frills Whatsoever:

Rent: $850
PG&E: $60
Food: $200

= $1,110 a month $13,320 a year.

But guess what? It's still ABOVE Poverty Level (one person). In 2015, the new Poverty Level for one person was listed (according to GOOGLE) as: $11,770 a year.

Federal and state wages have yet to match San Francisco's generous minimum wage standard.

In Chico, I made $10.00 an hour MAX. But even with that wage, I never made $11,770 a year. Why, you ask? Was I lazy or unemployed? No. I had two jobs then. The other job paid: $8.70 an hour. Even with these two jobs, I never made that much money -- not even enough to pay my rent of $795 a month.

I didn't have enough hours and the one job that gave me enough hours was cut but was only paying me $8.70 an hour. ($0.70 above Chico's minimum wage, but with forced union dues, I made less than that an hour).

It's a delicate balance between wage and hours worked to make a living. I've counted and re-counted this dozens of times to get a formula table fit to show any economist who dares insist that minimum wage standards are enough to live on.

Let's start with 20 hours, as the basis for part-time work...

20 hours a week.

Here's the breakdown on San Francisco's minimum wage and a part-time job of 20 hours per week.

$12.25/HR × 20 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $980 a month.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

That's $11,760 a year.

Guess what? You're making: LESS THAN POVERTY LEVEL! ($11,770 a year)

Forget paying the bills. Forget saving money. Forget going to school (even with financial aid, you have to shell out for books, paper/ink, etc.).

Let's try getting more hours...

$12.25/HR × 25 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $1,225 a month.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

$14,700 a year.

All right. Now things look less grim. You can make a living wage and maybe go to school if you have previous savings and are really, really lucky at not having any medical bills or catastrophes to upset this delicate financial balance.

$12.25/HR × 30 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $1,470 a month.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

$17,640 a year.

Great. Making a living wage with more money and the increased possibility of making it through school is a step in the right direction! Let's see how long this lasts.

$12.25/HR × 35 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $1,715 a month.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

$20,580 a year.

Yay! A proper living wage and United States living standard enough for you to pay your bills, go to school and maybe save for the future.

Oh wait... looks like I forgot something.

This is for a single person living in San Francisco, on "generous" minimum wage, granted an unheard of 35 hours per week without any cuts, excluding taxes and emergencies.

How many people actually make this much? Not many.

Let's do the math with $10.00 an hour, $9.00 an hour and $8.00 an hour...

$10.00/HR × 20 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $800 MO. $9,600 YR.
× 25 hours a week × 4 = $1,000 MO.      $12,000 YR.
× 30 hours a week × 4 = $1,200 MO.      $14,400 YR. 
× 35 hours a week × 4 = $1,400 MO.      $16,800 YR.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

$9.00/HR × 20 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $720 MO. $8,640 YR
× 25 hours a week × 4 = $900 MO.        $10,800 YR.
× 30 hours a week × 4 = $1,080 MO.     $12,960 YR.
× 35 hours a week × 4 = $1,260 MO.     $15,120 YR.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

$8.00/HR × 20 hours a week × 4 times a week (estimated paycheck arrival) = $640 MO. $7,680 YR
× 25 hours a week × 4 = $800 MO.        $9,600 YR.
× 30 hours a week × 4 = $960 MO.        $11,520 YR.
× 35 hours a week × 4 = $1,120 MO.     $13,440 YR.
(This does not include money subtracted for taxes, unemployment, etc.)

Notice the less you get per hour, the more hours you have to work to escape "Poverty Level". Since the Poverty Level is so unrealistic in this country, it doesn't take into account living standards in today's economy.

Imagine also, if you had a family to support on this income. Many single mothers (even with supposed government benefits) struggle to make ends meet, and they make above poverty level.

I did this to illustrate what money really means in a job. How even $1.00 more an hour can be the difference between living at poverty standards or scraping by at every-day standards.

I may not be an economist but any ordinary person can figure out the Poverty Level system is wrong and needs to be corrected immediately. No rich person can argue this evidence, saying that "we make a decent living" on such pitiful wages. Never mind the fact that employers are cutting wages and hours every which way they can. Even bank tellers have only 20 hours a week... You can find for yourself where they stand on the chart.

Having this information puts my job search in perspective and may hopefully help others bargain for better wages... unless it means getting laid off in your job. It's easier to bargain for more hours than for higher pay but even with more hours, employers will look at cutting you...

(as what happened to me at my other job).

If you dare to ask for living wages, more hours and a better life, you may get punished. But by not asking for this, you are living in a state unfit for our standards today in the United States of America, home to the greatest number of billionaires on the planet.

My financial circumstances mean little compared to the big picture of the economic crisis in America. Plenty of people get by living on the streets, though I'm not sure I'm willing to do that (yet). However, I think when everyone starts having this conversation, we can reach an agreement that there's a lot to be done concerning our budget and financial situation. Deciding what to do about it after, is another question (and a much more lengthy article to write).

For now, I'm still looking for a job. I'm saving my coins in the meantime. If I'm lucky, I'll have enough coins to do laundry next week (It's $6.75 to do laundry every week). Oh no... I forgot to budget for laundry! I guess when times get tough for me, I'll be the smelly person on the bus.